July 25, 2005
NEA: Parents should step aside "for the children"
The National Education Association (NEA) wants what's best for your kids, and it thinks what's best is for parents to mind their own business. In this case, the NEA says don't home school your kids. As the left often whines, it's for the chilllll-drennnnnn (Be sure to draw out the word "children" to make the whining sound realistic). On the other hand, maybe it's to protect the education establishment so that it can keep money in its pockets and keep indoctrinating your kids.
The NEA had one of its "top people" assess home schooling, which has become very popular and successful across the nation. Here's the article by Dave Arnold titled "Home Schools Run By Well-Meaning Amateurs". Countering that is a site run by a home schooling mother, who does this on her own time and on her own web site titled "Another Anti-Homeschooling Fisking". (As a good mom, she features her kids and her church, but the link is for her rebuttals to the NEA article.)
Most people who oppose home schooling often know little about it or have a financial or political interest in fighting it. People who have taught their own children have done it for altruistic reasons--doing what is best for their children as they view it. I trust parents to make the best decisions for their children. On the other hand, when education discussions touch home schooling, vouchers, and accountability: the NEA can always be found in opposition, which maybe is not usually best "for the children."
By the way, I should know something about this subject, as we home schooled our children for many years, and they are doing quite fine. We chose to obtain our resources through Calvert School, and there are many other professional programs for home schoolers including programs for military kids. You can judge for yourselves.
Oh, yes. The NEA author and expert, Dave Arnold, is head custodian at an elementary School in Illinois--a noble and useful job, but not one that would indicate that he is an expert on this subject. But, based upon its position, apparently the leaders at the NEA aren't either.
Posted by GM Roper at July 25, 2005 05:20 PM | TrackBackTHE NEA IS AGAINST HOMESCHOOLING BECAUSE THEY BELIEVE IT IS A THREAT TO THEM, BECAUSE HOMESCHOOLING CAN TURN OUT VERY SUCCESSFUL MOST OF THE TIME!THEY'RE AGAINST IT BECAUSE STATISTICS PROVES THEM WRONG ALL THE TIME!THE NEA IS AN ORGANIZATION THAT PRIDES ITSELF ON OPPOSING CHOICES IN EDUCATION FOR PARENTS AND STUDENTS!IT IS AGAINST ANY REFORM THAT WOULD ALLOW STUDENTS MORE OPPORTUNITIES, BECAUSE THEY DEEM CHOICE A THREAT!
Posted by Melanie Gertz at April 25, 2006 09:14 PM