October 03, 2007
One of my son's history books had only three paragraphs on World War II but had enough room for two full-page color pictures showing Bill Clinton and Maya Angelou. Fortunately, my son had a teacher who put together his own curiculum with articles and research papers that he collected over the years and on the topics where the textbooks failed.
Many students are not as fortunate, as evidenced by this sample of ninety students tested in San Francisco high schools.
If high school juniors' answers to a World War II questionnaire were strung together, here's how history would look:World War II took place in 19-something, when Theodore Roosevelt was president and the Germans claimed to be the best race.
Hoping to aid Third World countries, the United States joined the war to stop racism and end the dispute over Jews.
The head of the Nazis was a killer named Hitler whose evil partner, Mussolini, was president of the USSR. Ultimately, the war ended with the bombing of Iwo Jima and Hitler's suicide. Then a treaty was signed.
To make it worse, San Francisco city leaders never want to honor our military or teach that it has made people free throughout the world.
Parents need to be more involved and demand that their children get the education necessary to make livings and to learn history so as to avoid making mistakes of earlier generations. Education departments and teacher's unions need to start caring less about their power and more about "the children."
Posted at 03:50 AM
| Comments (5)
| Add Comment
Post contains 303 words, total size 2 kb.
Posted by: Faultline USA at Wednesday, October 03 2007 10:15 AM (deqQg)
It was particularly poignant, as both were born in Ceausescu's Romania, which erased much of the previous 100 years of history, finding it inconvenient.
Posted by: Assistant Village Idiot at Wednesday, October 03 2007 02:50 PM (YQFD4)
OR...
Teachers cannot always rely on parents to do their job. Textbooks are tailored to give bang for bucks. Teachers, for the most part, do the best they can with what they've got.
Woody...are you EVER planning on saying ANYTHING nice about teachers? Why not just take your son out of public school and home school him if it's that bad? You make these blanket statements about teachers being worthless and not giving a hoot. Unless you've been on a textbook committee, be quiet. You have no freaking idea what you are talking about. I've been on one, and it's hard. You have to look at the extras that each company is offering and decide which will be the most beneficial with the best results. It's not an easy decision.
Now...having said that, I personally agree that featuring only 3 paragraphs on WWII is terrible. But which bothers you more? That they only featured 3 paragraphs about WWII or that they put up a large picture of a president you despise and an author for whom I am sure you don't care? Which is it?
But I am sick to death of you always blaming the teachers. Everything that is wrong with the public school system is not always the teachers fault.
Are you on your son's PTA committee? What about the Campus Advisory Committee at your school? Do you volunteer at your son's campus? Do you tutor or offer to be mentor to someone? How are you involved? Have you ever even asked to be on a textbook committee for your district?
Posted by: Jennifer at Thursday, October 04 2007 02:11 PM (Pewaj)
Posted by: e. nonee moose at Friday, October 05 2007 12:14 AM (VK4T3)
Moose...um, no. Not doing it.
I agreed that the book did a disservice (putting it mildly) to WWII, but I'm tired of the Woody blaming the teachers for everything that's wrong. And every time he does it by making blanket statements that malign ME as a teacher, I will gripe, moan and complain forthwith.
Posted by: Jennifer at Friday, October 05 2007 04:30 PM (Pewaj)
Powered by Minx 1.1.4-pink.








